If you’ve ever bitten into a perfectly ripe Brandywine tomato, you know why gardeners have been growing this Amish heirloom for over a century. The rich, complex flavor and creamy texture make every other tomato taste like cardboard in comparison. But growing Brandywine tomatoes takes patience, proper support, and knowing what to expect from this legendary variety.
This guide walks you through everything you need to know about growing Brandywine tomatoes from seed to harvest, including the challenges that come with this notoriously finicky—but undeniably delicious—heirloom.
A Brief History of Brandywine
Brandywine tomatoes trace their roots back to the Amish communities of Pennsylvania and Ohio, where they’ve been passed down through generations since the 1880s. The variety was introduced to the broader gardening world by Seed Savers Exchange in 1982, and it quickly earned a cult following among tomato enthusiasts. The name likely comes from Brandywine Creek in Pennsylvania, though the exact origin story has been lost to time.
What hasn’t been lost is the flavor. Brandywine consistently ranks among the best-tasting tomatoes in taste tests, which is why gardeners continue to grow it despite its quirks and longer growing season.
Quick Reference: Brandywine at a Glance
Days to Maturity: 80-100 days from transplant
Plant Type: Indeterminate (continues growing all season)
Spacing: 24-36 inches between plants
Sunlight: Full sun (6-8 hours minimum)
Mature Height: 6-9 feet
Fruit Size: 10-16 oz typical (can reach 2 lbs)
Best Uses: Fresh eating, slicing, sandwiches
Hardiness Zones: 3-11
Support Required: Heavy-duty stakes or large cages
Starting Brandywine Tomatoes from Seed
Brandywine is a slow-maturing variety, so getting a head start indoors is essential in most climates.
When to Start Seeds
Start your Brandywine seeds indoors 6-8 weeks before your last expected frost date. If you’re in a shorter growing season (zones 3-5), lean toward 8 weeks to give plants maximum time to produce before fall frost. In warmer climates (zones 8-10), 6 weeks is usually sufficient.
Seed Starting Conditions
Brandywine seeds germinate best in warm soil. Keep your seed starting mix at 70-80°F for optimal germination. Use a heat mat if your indoor space runs cool. Seeds should sprout within 7-14 days, though some may take up to three weeks depending on conditions.
Sow seeds about 1/4 inch deep in your seed starting mix. Keep the soil consistently moist but not waterlogged. Once seedlings emerge, they need strong light—either a sunny south-facing window or grow lights positioned 2-3 inches above the plants for 14-16 hours daily.
For a complete walkthrough of the seed starting process, check out our guide on starting tomato seeds indoors.
Seedling Care
Once your Brandywine seedlings have their first true leaves (the second set that appears), you can begin feeding them with a diluted liquid fertilizer at half strength every two weeks. Keep them in temperatures around 65-70°F during the day and no cooler than 55°F at night.
Watch for leggy growth, which indicates insufficient light. If seedlings stretch toward light sources, move them closer to your grow lights or window.
Transplanting Brandywine Seedlings
Timing
Wait until all danger of frost has passed and nighttime temperatures consistently stay above 50°F. Brandywine plants are sensitive to cold and will sulk—or even experience permanent damage—if exposed to temperatures below 45°F. Soil temperature should be at least 60°F, ideally 65-70°F.
Hardening Off
Before planting outdoors, your seedlings need to gradually acclimate to outdoor conditions through a process called hardening off. Start by placing plants outside in a protected, shaded spot for just an hour or two, then bring them back inside. Over 7-10 days, gradually increase their time outdoors and exposure to direct sun and wind. Learn more in our hardening off seedlings guide.
Planting Depth
Here’s a trick that works especially well for Brandywine: bury the stem deep. Tomatoes can grow roots along their buried stem, creating a stronger root system. Remove the lower leaves and plant your seedling so that only the top 2-3 sets of leaves are above ground. If you have a very leggy seedling, you can even dig a horizontal trench and lay the stem sideways—it will curve upward naturally.
Initial Care
Water thoroughly after transplanting. Add a layer of mulch around the base of the plant, keeping it a few inches away from the stem to prevent rot. This conserves moisture and regulates soil temperature.
Growing Requirements for Brandywine Tomatoes
Soil
Brandywine thrives in rich, well-draining soil loaded with organic matter. Before planting, work in several inches of compost or well-aged manure. The ideal soil pH is between 6.0 and 6.8. If you’re unsure about your soil pH, a simple soil test from your local extension office can give you answers.
Poor drainage leads to disease problems, so if your soil is heavy clay, consider building raised beds or mounding up planting areas.
Fertilizing
Feed Brandywine plants every 2-3 weeks once they begin flowering. Use a balanced fertilizer (like 10-10-10) initially, then switch to a formula with less nitrogen and more phosphorus and potassium (like 5-10-10) once fruits begin setting. Too much nitrogen produces lush foliage but fewer fruits.
Side-dress plants with compost mid-season for an extra nutrient boost. Some gardeners swear by adding Epsom salts (1 tablespoon per plant monthly) for the magnesium, though results vary.
Watering
Consistency is crucial for Brandywine. These tomatoes are particularly prone to cracking when watering is erratic. Aim for 1-2 inches of water per week, either from rain or irrigation.
Water deeply at the base of plants rather than overhead to minimize disease risk. Morning watering is ideal so foliage dries before evening. Drip irrigation or soaker hoses work beautifully for tomatoes.
During fruiting, maintain even soil moisture. Swings between bone-dry and saturated soil cause the fruits to crack as they rapidly absorb water.
Mulching
Apply 2-4 inches of organic mulch (straw, shredded leaves, or grass clippings) around plants once the soil has warmed. Mulch keeps soil moisture consistent, suppresses weeds, and prevents soil-borne diseases from splashing onto lower leaves.
Supporting Brandywine Plants
This is non-negotiable: Brandywine absolutely requires sturdy support. These plants grow 6-9 feet tall and produce heavy fruits. Without proper support, branches break, fruits rot on the ground, and your harvest suffers.
When to Install Supports
Install stakes or cages at transplanting time, not later. Trying to drive a stake next to an established plant risks damaging the root system.
Best Support Methods
Flimsy tomato cages from the hardware store won’t cut it with Brandywine. You need:
- Heavy-duty stakes: 8-foot tall wooden or metal stakes (1.5-2 inches diameter) driven 12-18 inches into the ground
- Extra-large cages: 5-6 feet tall, made from concrete reinforcing wire or heavy-gauge welded wire
- Florida weave system: For multiple plants in a row, run twine between stakes to create support
As the plant grows, tie the main stem to your stake every 8-12 inches using soft plant ties, strips of fabric, or twine. Use a loose figure-eight pattern that allows for stem expansion.
For detailed instructions on each method, see our complete guide on supporting Brandywine tomatoes.
Pruning and Maintenance
Sucker Removal
Brandywine is an indeterminate tomato, meaning it continuously produces new growth. Small shoots called “suckers” emerge where branches meet the main stem. Some gardeners remove these to direct energy toward fruit production; others leave them for a bushier plant with more (but smaller) fruits.
For Brandywine, I recommend removing suckers below the first flower cluster and perhaps a few more in the middle of the plant to improve air circulation. Leave the rest—Brandywine’s naturally lower yield means you’ll want the extra fruiting branches.
Lower Leaf Pruning
Once plants are established and fruits begin setting, remove leaves on the lowest 10-12 inches of the plant. This improves air circulation and prevents soil-borne diseases from splashing onto foliage during watering or rain.
Late Season Topping
About 4-6 weeks before your first expected fall frost, you can “top” the plant by pinching off the growing tip. This stops upward growth and directs energy toward ripening existing fruits. This is optional but can help you get a few more ripe tomatoes before frost.
Common Problems with Brandywine Tomatoes
Cracking
This is the biggest complaint with Brandywine. The thin skin and inconsistent watering cause both radial cracks (from stem to bottom) and concentric rings around the stem. While you can’t eliminate cracking entirely, consistent watering and avoiding heavy nitrogen fertilization help. Pick cracked tomatoes immediately and use them within a day or two.
Blossom End Rot
Dark, sunken spots on the bottom of fruits indicate calcium deficiency, usually caused by inconsistent watering rather than lack of calcium in soil. Maintain even moisture and consider adding crushed eggshells or lime to your soil if it’s acidic.
Diseases
Brandywine is susceptible to common tomato diseases like early blight, late blight, and septoria leaf spot. Prevention strategies include proper spacing for airflow, avoiding overhead watering, mulching to prevent soil splash, and crop rotation (don’t plant tomatoes in the same spot more than once every three years).
For identification help and treatment options, see our guide on common tomato diseases.
Pests
Watch for tomato hornworms—large green caterpillars that can strip a plant overnight. Hand-pick them or spray with BT (Bacillus thuringiensis) for organic control. Aphids and whiteflies occasionally appear but rarely cause serious damage.
For more troubleshooting help, check out our detailed post on Brandywine tomato problems and solutions.
Harvesting Brandywine Tomatoes
When to Pick
This is critical: Brandywine must be vine-ripened for optimal flavor. Pick too early and you’ll wonder what the hype is about. Wait until fruits are deeply colored (pink-red for most Brandywine), give slightly when gently squeezed, and release easily from the stem with a gentle twist.
When you think a Brandywine is ready, give it another 2-3 days. That extra time makes all the difference in flavor development. For detailed ripeness indicators, read our guide on when to pick Brandywine tomatoes.
Yield Expectations
Plan on 10-20 pounds of tomatoes per Brandywine plant, or roughly 15-30 individual fruits depending on size. This is lower than hybrid varieties but typical for heirlooms. The payoff is in quality, not quantity. Learn more in our post about Brandywine tomato yields.
How to Harvest
Pick in the morning after dew has dried but before afternoon heat. Use a gentle twisting motion or scissors to remove fruits. Handle carefully—Brandywine bruises easily.
Storage
Store ripe Brandywine tomatoes at room temperature, stem-side up, out of direct sunlight. Never refrigerate unless you want to ruin the flavor and texture. Eat within 3-5 days for best quality.
Best Uses for Brandywine Tomatoes
Brandywine shines when eaten fresh. The complex, sweet flavor with balanced acidity makes it perfect for:
- Fresh slicing with just salt and pepper
- Caprese salad with mozzarella and basil
- The ultimate BLT sandwich
- Tomato salads and bruschetta
- Eaten like an apple (seriously, they’re that good)
What Brandywine Isn’t Great For
The very juicy texture that makes Brandywine amazing fresh makes it less ideal for canning or sauce. You’ll get a thin, watery sauce unless you cook it down for hours. For sauce and canning, stick with paste varieties like San Marzano or Amish Paste.
Is Brandywine Worth Growing?
Growing Brandywine tomatoes requires patience, sturdy support, and accepting some cracked fruits. The 80-100 day maturity time means you’re investing months of garden space and care into these plants.
But for tomato lovers, Brandywine is absolutely worth it. That first bite of a warm, perfectly ripe Brandywine tomato—juice running down your chin, complex sweet-tart flavor flooding your palate—justifies every bit of effort.
If you’re intrigued by other flavorful heirloom tomatoes, consider trying Cherokee Purple or Black Krim alongside your Brandywine. Each brings its own unique taste profile to your garden.
Ready to grow your own Brandywine tomatoes? Get high-quality Brandywine seeds here and start planning for your best tomato season yet.
Related Reading: